types of grading compared: A-F, standards-based, and excellent-satisfactory-needs improvement

Types of Grading: Honest Pros and Cons of 3 Systems

Types of Grading: Pros and Cons

Let’s look at a few types of grading used in schools. Whether you choose your grading system or inherit it from your school or district, it shapes how students see their progress, how parents read a report card, and how much time you spend at your desk. We will begin with the type that is probably the most widely used. For each, a list of pros and cons is provided. Keep in mind that none of these is the “right” answer for every classroom. Each fits some students, subjects, and grade levels better than others.


A-F

This is one of the major players in classrooms all over the world. Variations abound in the point system that represents these letter grades. As you know, A to D are passing grades, with A representing excellent, B good, C fair, and D poor (but passing). In my previous post, I talked about this type of grading. A system where an ~40% spread out of 100 points represents passing levels. And an ~60% spread from the same 100 points represents failure.

Pros

  • Easy to implement (Point values are assigned to each letter. Each assignment is also given point values. When the total points for an assignment are tallied, that translates to a letter grade. That letter then indicates a student’s skill with that assignment.)
  • Familiarity and wide usage

Cons

  • You can “split hairs” with the number-to-letter assignment (is 89.4 or 89.5 a B+ or an A-?)
  • At times it can be unfair ( 60-100 points out of 100 is a passing score, but 0-59 is failing)
  • Many consider it to be an unfair system for use in lower grade levels (meaning lower elementary)

Standards Grading

With the increasing use of state, local, and national standards, a standards system of grading can be used.

For example, a quiz, test, essay, lab, or presentation… is assigned that correlates with a particular standard. The teacher grades said assignment to determine whether it fits one of these categories: Exceeds, Meets, Not Meeting.

“Exceeds” and “Meets” mean that the student has met the instructor’s, school’s, and/or system’s criteria for that standard.

Pros

  • Students know where they stand on each standard
  • Simple Grading (easy for teacher)
  • Cuts down on time spent grading (Teachers don’t count every single activity as a standards-based criterion. They save that for the overarching assignments.)

Cons

  • Setting up good standards-based assignments takes time and careful discernment
  • (Once it is set up, the grading becomes easier.)

Excellent-Satisfactory-Needs Improvement

Like Standards-Based practices, this grading practice uses three or four categories to rank student achievement. Unlike standards-based grading, it works for any student work graded by the teacher.

Pros

  • Simple grading
  • Cuts down on time spent grading
  • Works well in lower grades

Cons

  • It can be an issue for upper elementary students
  • Not the best system for Middle School
  • Makes no sense for High School

Comparing the Types of Grading

Looking at these three side by side, a few patterns show up. The A-F system wins on familiarity, but its lopsided range (about 40% passing and 60% failing) bothers many teachers. Standards-based grading tells students where they stand on specific skills, but it takes time to set up. Excellent-Satisfactory-Needs Improvement is simple and quick, but it fits the lower grades better than middle or high school.

Notice that the systems that are easiest to grade are often the least detailed. The more information a grade communicates, the more work it usually takes to produce. That tradeoff is worth thinking about before you commit to any one system.


Choosing From the Types of Grading

If your school or district assigns the grading system, your flexibility lies in how you apply it: how you weigh assignments, handle late work, and give feedback. If you have more freedom, ask yourself a few questions:

  • What age group am I teaching?
  • What do I want a grade to tell students and parents?
  • How much time can I realistically spend grading each week?
  • Does my system treat effort, skill, and deadlines fairly?

There is no perfect answer. Many teachers find that a mix works best, and that is where the next post comes in.


Each of these types of grading has its place, and each has drawbacks. Next up: mastery grading, pass-fail, 1-4, and combination systems.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *